How to Cook Perfect Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad

Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad.

You can have Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad using 14 ingredients and 8 steps. Here is how you achieve that.

Ingredients of Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad

1. Prepare 5 lb of Bag Potatoes [washed - unpeeled].
2. You need 25 of Boiled Eggs [yep 25 - use older eggs - they peel easier].
3. It's 2 can of Black Olives [use only the firm ones - discard mushy ones].
4. You need 3 large of White Onions.
5. It's 6 large of Clausen Dill Pickles [no substitutions - these are the most delicious & crisp you'll find].
6. You need 3/4 cup of Whole Milk [add slowly until desired consistency].
7. You need 1 jar of Mayonnaise [use 2/3 to 3/4 jar].
8. It's 1 tbsp of Yellow Mustard.
9. Prepare 1/4 tsp of White Pepper.
10. You need 1/4 tsp of Celery Seed.
11. You need 1 tbsp of White Sugar [or more - add slowly to desired tastes].
12. You need of Paprika.
13. You need 3 of Celery Stalks [with leaves/tops].
14. You need 1 tsp of White Vinegar [to temper sweetness if needed].

Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad instructions

1. Bring [older] eggs to a boil in a large pot. Turn off heat. Once water has boiled - cover eggs and let them sit in that hot water for 18 minutes exactly undisturbed. Drain water and run under cold water immediately until eggs and pot have completely cooled off. This method will make perfect boiled eggs everytime with little discoloration. And, by using older eggs, they'll be very easy to peel..
2. Wash potatoes well. Do not peel. Then boil potatoes until you can easily run a knife through the largest potato. Drain and allow them to cool slightly..
3. Whip milk, mayo and spices in a very large bowl. You'll want your texture thick enough to coat and stick but, thin enough to mix easily..
4. Peel eggs and quarter. Chop vegetables..
5. ° Chop your warm potatoes into bite sized 1" pieces. Place potatoes into your chilled mayo mixture. Gently fold them in until they're fully coated. Your warm spuds will break up easily! ° It's important that your potatoes be warm upon mixing. They'll immediately begin to absorb your mayo/milk/spice mixture..
6. Gently incorporate your eggs and vegetables in with your potatoes. Again, fold in gently until everything is completely coated. If your mixture is too thick and not coating easily, just add a splash of whole milk and mix in your bowl. Repeat if necessary..
7. Lightly sprinkle Paprika on top of salad before serving..
8. Chill overnight if possible in a large covered bowl. Stir intermittently. Enjoy!.